Pick Buy Me a Coffee for small tips and Gumroad for selling files worldwide. Buy Me a Coffee takes 5% plus a 0.5% payout fee. Gumroad takes 10% plus $0.50. The card fee lands on both, so a $5 tip by US card leaves $4.27 on Buy Me a Coffee and $3.55 on Gumroad.
Gumroad vs Buy Me a Coffee splits on payouts and tax. Gumroad handles sales tax and pays banks in 119 countries. Buy Me a Coffee leaves tax to you and lists 49 payout countries. For selling files or memberships, CartMango (free right now, from $10 a year once paid plans start in November, 0% a sale plus Stripe’s card fee) leaves $4.55 of $5.
You have fans who want to pay you. Some would tip $5 after a good episode, and a few would buy a file or join for $5 a month.
Gumroad and Buy Me a Coffee both handle all of that now. Gumroad has its own coffee page, and Buy Me a Coffee runs a shop for downloads. The old line, products on one and tips on the other, no longer picks for you.
Both headline rates leave something out, and the gap is widest on small payments.
So which one keeps more of what your fans send? 3 things decide it: the size of each payment, where your bank is, and who files your sales tax.
Key Takeaways
- A $5 tip costs twice as much on Gumroad. Gumroad takes $1.45 of it with the card fee, and Buy Me a Coffee takes $0.73.
- Both sell files and take tips now. Gumroad has a built-in Coffee page, and Buy Me a Coffee runs a shop for downloads and memberships.
- Buy Me a Coffee pays out from $10. Gumroad’s first payout needs a $100 balance, and its weekly payouts hold each sale for 7 days.
- Of these 3, only Gumroad handles your sales tax. Gumroad is the merchant of record on every sale, while Buy Me a Coffee leaves VAT and sales tax to you.
- CartMango takes 0% a sale plus Stripe’s card fee. CartMango, the checkout I run, sells files and memberships, free right now, with paid plans from $10 a year in November.
Gumroad fees vs Buy Me a Coffee fees on a $5 tip, $20 file and $50 order
On a US card payment, Gumroad takes $1.45 of a $5 tip, $3.38 of a $20 file and $7.25 of a $50 order, while Buy Me a Coffee takes $0.73, $1.98 and $4.50.
Setting a price for your first file or monthly tier? A free email course, the Online Selling Mistakes Challenge, walks through the 5 selling mistakes solo creators make most, with a fix for each.
Both fees come in layers. Gumroad’s help page lists 10% + $0.50 per sale and says that figure does not include card processing at 2.9% + $0.30. A sale that comes through Gumroad’s Discover marketplace costs a flat 30% instead, with processing included. Buy Me a Coffee’s help center lists its 5% platform fee, then Stripe’s 2.9% + 30¢, then a 0.5% payout fee. It adds 1% when the supporter is outside the US and another 0.5% on subscription payments.
Fees take 29% of a $5 tip on Gumroad and 14.6% on Buy Me a Coffee, and on a $50 order the 2 shares fall to 14.5% and 9%, because Gumroad’s flat $0.50 matters less as the price rises.
| Setup | Plan cost | Keep on $5 | Keep on $20 | Keep on $50 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gumroad, direct sale, tip or member charge | $0 | $3.55 | $16.62 | $42.75 |
| Gumroad, Discover sale | $0 | $3.50 | $14.00 | $35.00 |
| Buy Me a Coffee, tip or shop sale | $0 | $4.27 | $18.02 | $45.50 |
| Buy Me a Coffee, monthly member | $0 | $4.24 | $17.92 | $45.25 |
| CartMango, file or membership | Free now, then $10 to $30 a year | $4.55 | $19.12 | $48.25 |
Every row except Discover adds a US card processing fee of 2.9% + $0.30, which Discover’s 30% already includes. Each fee is rounded to the cent before it comes off. A supporter outside the US adds 1% on Buy Me a Coffee, so a $5 monthly member from abroad leaves you $4.19, and Stripe’s own pricing adds 1.5% for international cards on any Stripe account, CartMango sellers included.
CartMango is the checkout I run, so read its row knowing that. Count CartMango’s plan too: once paid plans start, CartMango’s $10 Silver plan pays for itself within a year after 36 sales at $5 each against Buy Me a Coffee, or 10 against Gumroad.
Search this comparison and the summary at the top of Google puts Gumroad at a “10% flat fee” and Buy Me a Coffee at a “5% transaction fee”. The Gumroad line drops the $0.50. The Buy Me a Coffee line drops the card fee and the payout fee.

Buy Me a Coffee’s own comparison page, which ranks on page 1 for this search, drops the same 2 things: Gumroad’s $0.50 and every Buy Me a Coffee charge after the 5%. It says Gumroad charges “a 10% flat fee on sales made through your profile” and puts the gap at $50 on $1,000 of sales.
Run the full fees instead. On 200 tips of $5, the fees come to $290 on Gumroad and $146 on Buy Me a Coffee, a gap of $144. On 50 files at $20 the gap is $70. Our best platform guide found 3 of 6 page-1 guides on a different search leaving that $0.50 out too.
Gumroad vs Buy Me a Coffee: both sell files and take tips now
Gumroad and Buy Me a Coffee each take tips and sell downloads today, so the choice turns on cost per payment, payouts and tax.
Gumroad’s tip jar is its Coffee product, a product type of its own. Once your account is 30 days old you can add one, and it lives at a fixed address, yourname.gumroad.com/coffee. You set a suggested amount plus 2 more, and supporters can type any amount instead. The button reads Donate, Support or Tip. You get 1 Coffee page per account, and it cannot carry a file.
Gumroad also switches tipping on by default at checkout, so a buyer of a $20 file can add a tip on top. Its tipping article says you receive 100% of tips, minus standard Gumroad and Stripe or PayPal fees. A $5 Coffee tip on its own pays the full 10% + $0.50 plus the card fee, which is $1.45.
Buy Me a Coffee moved the other way. Its Shop sells digital downloads, services and physical items, with discount codes, pay-what-you-want pricing and lower prices for members. One-off support, memberships and the shop sit on the same page, and every sale pays the same 5% platform fee. With features roughly level, the 5 situations below come down to payment size, payouts and tax.
If most payments you get are $5 or less
Buy Me a Coffee is the cheaper home for small payments, because Gumroad’s flat $0.50 alone is 10% of a $5 tip before anything else is counted. This is the podcaster, writer or artist whose income arrives as $3 and $5 tips. On a $3 tip Gumroad takes $1.19, which is about 40%, while Buy Me a Coffee takes $0.56. On $5 it is $1.45 against $0.73.

A seller of $1 to $3 gaming products hit exactly this, in an r/ecommerce thread: “for $58 in sales, I paid $46 in fees, ending up with just $12.” On a single $1.02 sale they kept 9 cents. That is what 10% + $0.50 plus the card fee leaves, to the cent.
Further down, a creator who sells mostly on Buy Me a Coffee called it “Just a 5% flat fee, nothing else,” and added that covering the card fee is optional. That leaves out the 0.5% payout fee in Buy Me a Coffee’s own help center.
What you give up on Buy Me a Coffee is mostly small print. The card fee comes out of your share unless you switch off a setting called Cover credit card fee, and then a supporter who gives $25 pays $26.03. Supporters abroad add 1%, memberships add 0.5%, and nobody collects sales tax for you.
If tips are nearly everything you earn, Ko-fi deserves a look too. It takes 0% of a one-off tip once you turn off its default Standard mode, which our Payhip vs Ko-fi comparison walks through.
If you earn under $100 a month
Buy Me a Coffee’s payout minimum is $10, while Gumroad’s first payout needs a $100 balance, a long wait when your tips add up to a few dollars a week.
Gumroad’s standard schedules are weekly, monthly or quarterly, and each sale sits in your balance for at least 7 days first. The $100 minimum applies to all 3, and some countries have a higher local minimum. US sellers can later take instant payouts of any settled amount from $1, for a 3% fee, but only after a first payout and 60 days of processing with Gumroad.
The $100 floor replaced a $10 one in March 2026, which our Gumroad review traced through seller complaints. A seller in an r/DigitalProductSellers thread wrote that Gumroad “changed the min payout from $10 to $100 without any warning,” and a reply pointed to Ko-fi and Buy Me a Coffee instead.
Say your fans send 8 tips of $5 a month. Gumroad’s fees take $11.60 and leave $28.40, so your first payout waits until month 4 at the earliest. Buy Me a Coffee’s fees take $5.84 and leave $34.16, and you can ask for it in the first month.
The catch on Buy Me a Coffee is a review. Its FAQ says the moderation team checks your account before the first payout, and the money then travels through Stripe to your bank, which only works in the countries on its payout list.
If your bank is outside Buy Me a Coffee’s 49 payout countries
Gumroad is the pick when you live outside Buy Me a Coffee’s payout list, because Gumroad pays banks in 119 countries and falls back to PayPal for most others.
Buy Me a Coffee pays out through Stripe, so it can only pay where Stripe supports it. Its help center lists 44 countries on Stripe Standard and 5 more on Stripe Express: India, Israel, the Philippines, South Korea and Türkiye. Its FAQ page says 44. If your country is on neither list, Buy Me a Coffee cannot pay you out.
Gumroad’s payout article lists bank payouts in local currency for 119 countries. Where bank payouts are not offered, Gumroad sends PayPal in US dollars with a 2% payout fee, and a number of countries get neither. The fees stay the same either way: a $20 sale costs $3.38 on Gumroad, plus 2% at payout if your money goes by PayPal.
The $100 minimum applies here too. If you move abroad, changing your payout country can forfeit unpaid money held on a country-specific account, so cash out first.
If buyers in the EU download your files
Gumroad suits files sold across borders, because Gumroad is the merchant of record on every sale and collects and pays the sales tax and VAT itself.
Buy Me a Coffee does not. Its tax article says it has no built-in tools to add sales tax or VAT to purchases, and that working out, charging and paying it is your job. Under EU VAT rules, standard rates cannot be less than 15%.
On a $20 file Gumroad takes $3.38 against $1.98 on Buy Me a Coffee. That extra $1.40 a sale is what Gumroad charges for taking the tax job off you, along with its other selling tools. Once a calendar month passes $20,000 in paid sales, Gumroad’s rate on direct sales drops to 5% + $0.50 for the rest of that month. Discover sales still cost 30%.
If your tip page now sells more files than coffees
CartMango fits once files or memberships sold to your own followers outgrow the tips, because CartMango takes 0% of each sale and you pay Stripe’s card fee plus, once paid plans start, a yearly plan. Think of a creator whose $5 coffees turned into a $20 pack of brushes, presets or templates, bought by people who already follow them. On that $20 file CartMango leaves $19.12, Buy Me a Coffee $18.02 and Gumroad $16.62, so CartMango’s $10 plan pays for itself after 10 such sales against Buy Me a Coffee, or 4 against Gumroad.
CartMango is free right now, then $10, $20 or $30 a year once paid plans start in November. CartMango’s $10 Silver plan covers 10 products, 2 GB of file storage, one-time and subscription selling, coupons, pay-what-you-want pricing and order bumps. CartMango’s upsells and cart abandonment start on the $20 Gold plan, and its payouts go straight to your own Stripe or PayPal account. For members, CartMango’s subscriptions keep paying you if you ever leave CartMango. Our guide to selling subscriptions online compares what a $10-a-month member costs on 6 tools.
CartMango has real gaps next to these 2. It has no dedicated tip page (pay-what-you-want pricing is the closest thing), no fan feed and no marketplace, and like Buy Me a Coffee it leaves sales tax to you. CartMango does not host video files, so a video course stays on a host such as YouTube or Vimeo. If your fans mostly tip, stay on Buy Me a Coffee. If you want tax handled or strangers finding you through a marketplace, Gumroad does that.
The 5 situations side by side
Buy Me a Coffee is the cheaper tip jar and pays out from $10, Gumroad pays out to more countries than Buy Me a Coffee and handles your tax, and CartMango takes 0% a sale, so a $20 file costs $0.88 in card fees plus a yearly plan once paid plans start.
| Your situation | Pick | Cost vs rival | The catch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Most payments are $5 or less | Buy Me a Coffee | $0.73 of a $5 tip ($1.45 on Gumroad) | Card fee is yours by default, +1% abroad |
| You earn under $100 a month | Buy Me a Coffee | Payout from $10 ($100 first payout on Gumroad) | First payout waits on a review |
| Bank outside the 49 countries | Gumroad | $3.38 of a $20 sale ($1.98 on Buy Me a Coffee) | $100 first payout, 2% on PayPal payouts |
| Buyers in the EU | Gumroad | $3.38 of a $20 sale ($1.98 on Buy Me a Coffee) | 30% on Discover sales |
| Files outsell coffees | CartMango | $0.88 of a $20 sale ($1.98 on Buy Me a Coffee), plus a plan after beta | No tip page, tax is yours |
FAQ
Why are people leaving Gumroad?
Seller complaints land on the fee, payouts and suspended accounts. Gumroad takes 10% + $0.50 on each direct sale before the card fee, and its first payout now needs a $100 balance. In our Gumroad review, 46 of 68 recent seller reviews on Trustpilot described a suspended account, a held payout or that $100 minimum.
Is Buy Me a Coffee reputable?
Yes, for tips and a small shop. Buy Me a Coffee’s card payments run through Stripe, its FAQ says you can export your supporter list any time you like, and the company is based in San Francisco. Your first payout waits on a moderation review, and an account with no login for 18 months has its page unpublished.
What is better than Buy Me a Coffee?
For tips alone, Ko-fi takes 0% of a one-off tip once you switch off its default Standard mode. For selling files to buyers abroad with the tax handled, Gumroad does more of the work for 10% + $0.50. For files and memberships sold to your own followers, CartMango takes 0% a sale plus Stripe’s card fee.
What’s better than Gumroad?
For lower fees on files, Payhip’s free plan takes 5% a sale, and CartMango takes 0% a sale plus Stripe’s card fee. Gumroad takes 10% + $0.50. Our best Gumroad alternative guide compares 7 alternatives side by side.
Should you use Gumroad or Buy Me a Coffee, or both?
Use Buy Me a Coffee if most payments are small tips, and Gumroad if you sell files to buyers abroad and want the tax handled. You can also run both: the coffee button on Buy Me a Coffee and the files on Gumroad. You then have 2 dashboards and 2 payout floors, $10 and $100, and only the Gumroad sales get their tax collected for you.
What happens to a Buy Me a Coffee page you stop using?
After 12 months with no login, Buy Me a Coffee starts sending weekly reminder emails. At 18 months it unpublishes the page, pays any balance to your connected payout method, or refunds your supporters if no payout method is connected. A single login at any point resets the clock.
When the fans who tip start buying files
Whichever way the Gumroad vs Buy Me a Coffee choice goes for tips, the per-sale cut on files and memberships is the number that grows with you, and CartMango takes that cut to 0%.
CartMango charges no per-sale fee on any plan, so each sale costs only Stripe’s card fee, and members keep paying you if you ever move on. It is free right now, then from $10 a year once paid plans start in November.
About the Author

👋 I’m Welly, founder of CartMango (the site you’re on), a checkout platform for digital product sellers. We’ve previously processed $179M+. I also run BirdSend (email marketing tool, 3.1B+ emails sent). On the side I show other non-techie digital sellers how I use AI workflows to automate 50%+ of my operations. Find me on LinkedIn.
Related Reading
- Best Gumroad alternative: 7 alternatives priced against Gumroad’s 10% + $0.50
- Gumroad review: what recent seller reviews on Trustpilot complain about most
- Sell subscriptions online: what a $10-a-month member costs you on 6 tools
- Payhip vs Ko-fi: a tip page against a digital store, and who handles the tax
